pisdoff
member
We recently moved FineWoodworking.com to a new domain. If you are having trouble accessing member content or links in your Favorites folder you may need to login to the site again. If you forgot your login information, you can reset your password or contact Customer Service.

Taunton Home | Books & Videos | Contact Us | Customer Service | FAQs
Privacy Policy | User Agreement | Copyright Notice | Taunton Guarantee | About Us | Work for Us | Advertise | Press Room
Fine Woodworking | Fine Homebuilding | Fine Cooking | Fine Gardening | Threads | CraftStylish | JUNKMARKET Style | Vegetable Gardener
Recent comments
Re: Who Begot Who? Comparing Planes from Lie-Nielsen, Wood River and Stanley
Fred west: How can you consider it undercutting?
posted: 11:32 am on June 4thIt is simply supplying an alternative for those who cannot afford a L N.
Not everyone can afford a Cadillac, that's why
makes Chevys.
Re: Who Begot Who? Comparing Planes from Lie-Nielsen, Wood River and Stanley
Woodshaver, nobody is arguing that point. The argument is what do you do if you can't afford them?
posted: 11:26 am on June 4th$300 or so buys an awful lot of food, and mostly anything else.
Re: Who Begot Who? Comparing Planes from Lie-Nielsen, Wood River and Stanley
Yankeewoodworker states 'I've made a practice of giving gifts of ln hand planes'. I only have one question:
posted: 11:07 am on June 4thWhat do I have to do to become your best friend:-)
Re: Who Begot Who? Comparing Planes from Lie-Nielsen, Wood River and Stanley
Krenovian writes 'don't give me that rationale about ln planes being unaffordable'.
posted: 10:47 am on June 4thThat's not a rationale, that's reality. If you can afford the best, by all means buy it. I don't think there are many who would deny that LN is the best either.
The fact of the matter is, they are expensive! If you couldn't afford a Cadillac (maybe a poor comparison at the moment, but I'm sure you get the historical implication), should you go without a car until you have saved up enough to get one? Or does it make sense to go buy a Chevy or a Hundai or whatever to fulfill your basic needs?
I don't think anyone believes they are getting a LN on the cheap when they buy a wood river or whatever, but if it is an affordable substitute......